With the assistance of E.H. Williams II Law & Strategy PLLC, as lead counsel to the Hispanic Scholarship Fund (HSF), the parties have resolved American Alliance for Equal Rights v. Hispanic Scholarship Fund, No. 25-cv-4207 (D.D.C.). A joint stipulation of dismissal with prejudice was filed on November 9, 2026. The settlement has been reported in The New York Times. Founding Principal Edward Williams is quoted in The Times as noting that HSF pursued the case because it did not want to be bullied and wanted to vindicate the right of organizations to provide race conscious scholarships.
The case challenged the eligibility criteria of the HSF Scholar Program under 42 U.S.C. § 1981, Title VI, and two state civil rights statutes. On September 30, 2026, the court dismissed the Title VI claim with prejudice and declined jurisdiction over the state-law claims. It also rejected several of the contract theories AAER relied on to bring the program within Section 1981. The court held that website terms of use and privacy policies, a “property” clause in the application, and a required essay did not make the program a contract. It described the scholarship awards as charity, not payment for services. The Section 1981 claim survived only on narrower theories tied to promises students make to the provider, such as conference commitments, surveys, content and likeness licenses, and, on the allegations as pleaded, conditions on the use of scholarship funds.
Under the settlement, HSF will open the Scholar Program to students regardless of ethnicity beginning with the January 2027 cycle. HSF paid no damages, and no AAER member will receive Program funds. The stipulation records that HSF does not read the court’s opinion to bar scholarships offered exclusively to Hispanic students, that AAER disagrees, and that neither side admits anything.
“I could not be more proud than to have represented HSF in this incredibly important case. This decision will help to slowly turn the tide on the onslaught of cases in recent years that have put race conscious scholarship programs on their heels,” said Mr. Williams.
The opinion is a ruling on a motion to dismiss, not a determination that any program is or is not lawful. It does, however, offer scholarship providers a practical way to review their own application, award, and program documents.
Mr. Williams was joined as counsel for HSF by lawyers at Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP and the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation.
Our Program Defensibility Review helps scholarship providers, universities, and nonprofits apply this analysis to their own documents before a complaint arrives. Contact us to learn more.